- Singer cleared of organising £820 drug deal between friend and reporter
- She believed Mazher Mahmood was a powerful Hollywood film producer
- Judge Alistair McCreath told the jury that the case 'cannot go any further'
- Judge said there were 'strong grounds to believe' that Mr Mahmood 'lied'
- Mahmood's driver Alan Smith was central to the collapse of today's case
- He picked Tulisa up from a hotel where she spoke out against taking drugs
- However after talking to Mahmood, Smith changed his crucial evidence
- Her friend Mike GLC was also cleared despite pleading guilty before the trial
- Tulisa said 'we have now succeeded in exposing the real culprit and liar'
- Sun confirm Mahmood 'suspended pending immediate internal investigation'
Former
X-Factor judge Tulisa Contostavlos has today been cleared of supplying
cocaine after a judge threw out the case against her at Southwark Crown
Court.
She had been accused of brokering a deal to supply £820 of the drug to an undercover reporter.
The judge today ruled that Sun undercover reporter Mazher Mahmood gave 'entirely inconsistent evidence'.
The
collapse of today's trial is the latest scandal to hit News UK, who
under the company's previous guise, News International, was forced to
shut the News of the World following revelations of phone hacking.
Walking: Pop star Miss Contostavlos looked happy as she left Southwark Crown Court in central London today
Statement: Contostavlos said her life had been put on hold for the past year while she dealt with the allegations
Following
the dramatic development News UK has confirmed that Mr Mahmood has been
'suspended pending an immediate internal investigation'.
The
court heard the collapse of the case hinged on evidence given by Mr
Mahmood about a statement given to police by a driver called Alan Smith
who picked up Miss Contostavlos from a hotel in London in May last year.
Mr
Smith originally suggested he had heard the star talking disapprovingly
about drugs but 'changed his mind' after a conversation with the
undercover reporter, the court was told.
During
a pre-trial hearing Mr Mahmood was asked: 'Did you subsequently ask or
find out, discuss with Mr Smith anything that was said in the car?'
Rapper Michael
Coombs, known as Mike GLC also had charges against him thrown out at
Southwark Crown Court despite pleading guilty at the beginning of the
trial after the judge ruled the evidence had been tainted
Probe: The Sun defended the original
investigation but said Mr Mahmood (believed to be shown in this image)
had been suspended pending an internal inquiry
He replied: 'No.'
Asked if at any stage he discussed Miss Contostavlos saying she 'disapproved' of drugs, he also said no.
But
the judge said he gave answer which were 'entirely inconsistent' when
he gave evidence about the same topic at the trial last week.
Outside the court, Miss Contostavlos said her life had been put on hold for the past year while she dealt with the allegations.
She
said: 'As my lawyer said at the outset, we have now succeeded in
exposing the real culprits and most importantly, the real liar.
‘As
someone who has had my life ruined for the past year, I strongly
believe that this type of entrapment should not happen to anyone.
'I
urge both the police and News UK to investigate Mazher Mahmood and his
team and to put an end to his deceit in pursuit of sensational stories
for commercial gain.'
She said: 'I
have never been involved in either taking or dealing cocaine. This
whole case was a horrific and disgusting entrapment by Mazher Mahmood
and the Sun on Sunday newspaper.'
'Mahmood
has now been exposed by my lawyers as lying to the judge and jury.
These lies were told to stop crucial evidence going before the jury.
This evidence showed that I told Mahmood's long-standing driver that I
disapproved of drugs - which is the truth.'
'It is clear that the driver was pressurised to change statement to strengthen Mahmood's evidence and to do damage to mine.'
She
called on News UK and the Metropolitan Police to investigate Mr
Mahmood. She said the Sun on Sunday reporter had tricked her by making
her think she was auditioning for a major movie role.
Explaining
his decision to halt the case to the jury, the judge said:
'Occasionally - very rarely - circumstances may arise in which a court
has to say that whatever apparent merits a prosecution may have, the
court cannot allow the prosecution case to be taken forward to trial.'
He said the situation arose from a 'fundamental principle' that the court 'cannot allow itself to be party to improper conduct'.
Tulisa
Contostavlos called on the Metropolitan Police to investigate Mazher
Mahmood after being cleared of arranging a drug deal. She said he had
been 'exposed lying to the judge and the jury'
The
judge went on: 'Where there has been some aspect of the investigation
or prosecution of a crime which is tainted in some way by serious
misconduct to the point that the integrity of the court would be
compromised by allowing the trial to go ahead, in that sense the court
would be seen to be sanctioning or colluding in that sort of behaviour,
then the court has no alternative but to say, "this case must go no
further".'
It
can now be reported that before the trial began, defence counsel argued
that the case should be 'stayed' - meaning thrown out - but their
application was turned down.
But giving his ruling today, the judge said 'matters have moved on since then'.
Dismissing the case, Judge Alistair
McCreath claimed there is a 'fundamental principle' that if the
investigation of a crime is tainted by serious misconduct 'the court
would be compromised by allowing the trial to go ahead'
The Sun defended the original investigation but said Mr Mahmood had been suspended pending an internal inquiry.
A
spokesman said: 'We are very disappointed with this outcome, but do
believe the original investigation was conducted within the bounds of
the law and the industry's code. This was demonstrated by the CPS (Crown
Prosecution Service) decision to prosecute.
'The
Sun, of course, takes the judge's remarks very seriously. Mr Mahmood
has been suspended pending an immediate internal investigation.'
Arriving in court this morning one of Tulisa's heels got caught in a drain and had to be retrieved
Tulisa, pictured second right, heard today that the case against her 'cannot go any further'
The
singer was accused of boasting that she could 'sort out' cocaine for a
journalist and put him in touch with her rapper friend Mike GLC, who
supplied the Class A drug.
Undercover
reporter Mr Mahmood, dubbed the 'Fake Sheikh', posed as a wealthy film
producer called Samir Khan when he met the former X Factor judge at a
string of luxury hotels and restaurants, jurors at London's Southwark
Crown Court heard.
Contostavlos vehemently denied brokering the deal, which was exposed in the Sun on Sunday newspaper last June.
Today
judge Alistair McCreath told the jury that the case 'cannot go any
further' because there were 'strong grounds to believe' that Mr Mahmood
had 'lied' at a hearing before the trial started.
The 26-year-old star smiled broadly in the dock as the jury was formally discharged from trying the case.
Tulisa, pictured arriving at court today, smiled broadly in the dock as the charges against her were dismissed
Miss
Contostavlos appeared ecstatic, punching the air as she left the dock
before crying as she hugged supporters including her PA, Gareth Varey,
shortly after the case against her was thrown out.
Mike
GLC - whose real name is Michael Coombs - pleaded guilty before the
start of the trial to supplying half an ounce (13.9g) of cocaine but he
also walked free after judge said the case cannot proceed against him.
The 36-year-old also wept as he hugged defence barrister Jeremy Dein QC.
The topsy-turvy world of Tulisa from the 'ghetto'
Tulisa Contostavlos was still a teenager when she first found fame.
She
teamed up with her cousin Dappy and their friend Fazer in N-Dubz, a
reference to north London where they grew up, while they were still at
school.
The
first of more than 10 top 40 hits came in 2007 and by 2010 she had
moved into television and was presenting a documentary about young
people caring for parents with mental health problems which drew on her
own experiences growing up with her mother.
Tulisa, centre, found fame with her
band N-Dubz, she founded with her cousin Dino 'Dappy' Contostavlos,
left, and Richard 'Fazer' Rawson, right, who had their first hit in 2007
before moving on into television presenting
She
also featured in the Channel 4 fly-on-the-wall show Being ... N-Dubz,
which followed the group over two series, but she really hit the big
time in 2011 when she joined the judging panel on Simon Cowell's show
The X Factor.
She
described it as her 'dream job' and stormed to success at the first
attempt, helping pull in some of its highest ever viewing figures and
steering her girl group Little Mix to victory.
The
singer stayed on for another series but the high-profile show put her
own private life under the spotlight and revelation after revelation
ended up on the front pages.
Along
the way, Tulisa spoke candidly about her troubled childhood which
included a suicide attempt and self-harm and confessed to feeling out of
place on the show, saying: 'I'll think, "I don't belong here."
'I
get those moments now and again. Although I can be very feisty, that's a
defence mechanism for me. I'm defensive because too many years of my
life I was treated like s***.'
There was also controversy when spin-off show The Xtra Factor was rapped by TV watchdog Ofcom for promoting her perfume.
In
2012, she signed a publishing deal for two novels and an autobiography
which detailed for the first time how she was drugged and sexually
abused when she was 16 and also revealed her involvement in a girl gang.
Later
that year, she said she was 'devastated' after a video of her sharing
an 'intimate moment' with an ex-boyfriend was circulated on the
internet.
The
singer told fans she had been 'deeply betrayed' and took legal action
which ended months later with her at London's High Court accepting
"sincere apologies" from ex-boyfriend Justin Edwards.
She
told reporters the rapper had 'messed with the wrong woman' and that
she was a 'stronger, wiser young woman who has taken this experience and
learnt from it'.
Her
love life - including a relationship with footballer Danny Simpson -
kept her on the front pages as her career started to flag with
lacklustre sales for her debut solo album, which one critic described as
having 'a pound-shop Rihanna sound'.
Worse
was to follow last year when she was axed from The X Factor, telling
fans on Twitter 'it's time to do something different'.
A
month later she was accused of boasting that she could 'sort out'
cocaine for an undercover journalist. She vehemently denied brokering
the deal and punched the air when the trial collapsed today, declaring
outside court: 'This whole case was an horrific and disgusting
entrapment.'
No comments:
Post a Comment